This is a list of all the arguments I can think of against gay marriage/gay rights.
And why they're wrong. :)
1. Gay couples can't have children.
Alright. Like, do I even have to say this is bullshit? Because I shouldn't have to. But I will.
This.
Is.
BULLSHIT.
There's artificial insemination and adoption and, besides that, does the world really need more children? China was limiting families to one child for a while because of overpopulation, not to mention all of the children in foster homes that would love to have a loving couple take care of them. And I'm going to take a wild guess and say they really don't give a fuck if the couple is gay or straight.
And I won't even touch on the fact that there are infertile straight couples. That'd be too much.
2. Children need a male and female role model. Gay couples only supply one gender.
Okay. So first of all, if gay couples can't have children (see #1) then this shouldn't really be a problem...
And second of all, are we going to prohibit single parents from having kids? What if a straight couple gets divorced and one parent doesn't get custody rights? What if the parents die and the child is cared for by a widowed grandparent? I mean, do I need to keep going...?
3. Homosexuality is a stepping stone to beastiality.
This makes me laugh.
I would like to point out (as it seems to have escaped the notice of many Americans) that there is a difference between me having sex with another woman, and me having sex with a goat. In fact, not only is there a difference, there's really no relation at all.
Furthermore, I would argue that there are more similarities between straight sex and beastiality than there are between gay sex and beastiality seeing as in the first, there's at least two different genders...
4. Homosexual marriages will lead to polygamy.
Really my only argument against this is that I have no desire to marry five different people.
But, on a related topic, I once watched a debate over gay marriage on the Dr. Phil show via YouTube. Aside from the fact that Dr. Phil is a complete tool, the debate was actually pretty interesting. One man, who I believe was a Latter Day Saint, said that (and I'm paraphrasing) he thought that because the LDS Church had given up their polygamous practices to be a part of this country, gay people shouldn't expect "special treatment."
Dude. It's not my fault the LDS Church didn't have the balls to stand up for themselves. Just saying.
5. Gay people will recruit children.
So assuming that you could "recruit" children to be gay, I really don't like kids. I find them to be annoying. I have no desire to spend my time "recruiting" them.
But, on top of that, how exactly do you recruit a child? Like, if a math teacher tries to persuade a student to major in math at college, is that the same thing? Is there a class you can take in recruiting children to be gay? Is this something gay people are born knowing how to do? Because I think I missed that memo... Woops.
And, furthermore, if it were possible for us to recruit children, why would we be wasting our time trying to convince all the homophobes that we were right? It seems to me like it would be a lot easier to just recruit all of their children and then go, "HA. WE'VE GOT YOUR CHILDREN AND WE'RE HOLDING THEM RANSOM UNTIL WE GET OUR RIGHTS!"
Seeing as that hasn't happened yet...
6. Gay people can have civil unions, but marriage is only between one man and one woman.
Hi. Welcome to the 21st Century. Here, we don't believe in the "separate but equal" doctrine. In fact, that ideology was ruled unconstitutional and stupid over 50 years ago in Brown v. Board of Education. If you have any other questions about this new century, please feel free to ask. We like to welcome people that were clearly born yesterday.
7. God hates homosexuals.
I can't believe this is even an argument. SEPARATION OF CHURCH AND STATE, MOTHERFUCKERS! Otherwise, can we go with this religion?
http://www.bbc.co.uk/religion/religions/rastafari/customs/customs_1.shtml
Then we can legalize pot no problem, right?
And, even if we didn't have that, who says that the religions that forbid homosexuality are the ones we should be paying attention to? Like, what about Unitarian Universalists? They don't seem to have a problem with homosexuality.
8. The Bible says being gay is a sin.
Right. I think this a great argument. We should all go around following the advice of a 2,000 year old book. Maybe in the year 4,000 A.D. they'll start worshipping a young man named Harry Potter, the god that defeated the evil Voldemort and rescued us all from being slaves to the wizards.
And not to mention the fact that everyone follows all of the principles of the Bible. I know that my dad offered me up to a group of ravaging sinners so that they wouldn't rape the angels as soon as I was of age. It was a beautiful bonding moment for us.
...
9. Being gay is a choice.
Yeah, all us gay people just woke up one morning and said to ourselves, "Gosh, I bet it would be fun to be told repeatedly that I'm going to hell, that God hates me, that I'm a faggot, and that I don't deserve to be loved. OH! And then maybe my parents will reject me and my friends will hate me, and I'll get bullied at school or get fired from my job. And, best of all, I won't be able to get married! If only there were some way to make that happen... OH HEY! I CAN BE GAY!" Yup. That's how it went down.
Also: when did you decide to be straight? Did a teacher recruit you too???
No? Didn't think so.
In summary:
Homophobes can shove their crap arguments up their collective ass.